Validation – A One-shot Story

By Gary Smith

This story begins around New Year’s Eve 2024 when I happened to be browsing YouTube and I watched a video entitled: The Film Camera You Should Actually Buy. Some may recall other posts I’ve made here beginning a year ago or so dealing with various camera purchases and problems. In any case, the video suggested that the Nikon FE was important enough that I should go looking for one.

I never owned a Nikon – not in the 50 years or so that I’ve been shooting photographs.

A quick visit to eBay followed by a: BUY IT NOW and I had a seventh film camera on the way.

It arrived from Japan on 8 January and the e-Series Nikon 36-72/3.5 zoom lens promptly fell apart. The zoom barrel/focus ring completely fell off the rest of the lens body and it didn’t seem to want to go back on. I’m not big on DIY but to be honest, if I had to purchase another lens, my $82.00 bargain wasn’t going to be much of a bargain (in my head I’m calling it $82 because if I add in the $34 shipping it doesn’t seem like a bargain any longer).

An on-line post to DPReview yielded a helpful link to: Richard Haw’s Classic Nikon Maintenance which described working on that very lens. I would imagine that many Nikon owners are familiar with Richard’s site as it contains a wealth of experience distilled into concise articles describing fixes to various Nikon issues.  Halfway down Richard’s article about this lens he begins describing maintenance with the following warning:

“This lens is best left to the professional repairman to tackle. If you are new to lens repair just skip this one until you have acquired the right skills, this will require some special tools to service properly.”

I’d worked on mechanical wristwatches in the past and had the tools, I just need the confidence. In short order and armed with the confidence of Richard’s article I had the front element off the zoom/focus barrel, and I was able to re-engage the helicoid and re-assemble the lens.

My new-to-me Nikon needed film and I had decided that it would be color. I also decided that I’d brave the temperature-controlled world of home development and give that a shot as well. The camera was clumsily loaded with 36 exposures of Fujifilm Superia 400 color negative film. Let me say that of all the 35mm cameras that I have loaded with film, the Canon FTb is by far the easiest. My first load in the Nikon resulted in not getting the film notched into the take-up spool and upon that realization, I started again and decided to trash the first 10 shots.

I had decided to use CineStll’s Cs41 “Color Simplified” 2-Bath Kit which I ordered along with a few other odds and ends. One recommendation that I had received was to use a Sous Vide device to maintain the temperature and circulation of my water bath. This ended up working quite well although it also added to my investment in handling color film.

With the camera loaded and various supplies on the way, I ventured out to expose the remaining 26 or so exposures. I took the Nikon along with me on a Bald Eagle shoot some 60 miles east of home. I ended up finishing off the remaining few shots at the McMenamins Edgefield property where my wife and I were married and where we spend time during summer evening enjoying a glass of wine and listening to music. Edgefield used to be the county “poor farm” but it was resurrected and is now a local destination. The shot above was taken at Edgefield and is (the back side) of one of several bars located around the property.

Using a trusty “church key” I cracked open the film canister and loaded my developing tank (sitting on the floor of my darkened bedroom closet). I mixed up my two bath chemicals and adjusted the temperature of my water bath. After 12 minutes or so at 102 degrees F my negatives looked like they were supposed to look. Letting them dry for a day I proceeded to scan them using a Valoi Easy35 and a 42mp Sony a7R3 as described previously here.

One critical difference between doing black and white v. color is that the whole inversion process isn’t as trivial. I ended up adding more to my investment in color film by purchasing Film Lab to do the color inversion. While Negative Lab Pro (NLP) seems to be the popular choice for conversion it is probably largely driven by the predominance of Adobe use. I don’t own any Adobe photo s/w so I wanted an inversion solution that was one-click that didn’t require Adobe. After watching some YT videos on Film Lab I was convinced when I saw you could “cut and paste” your edit criteria from one frame to your entire roll. This would work well if all of your shots were properly exposed and needed the same cropping. Mine were not but the above one shot represents validation that:

  • My lens repair worked,
  • My lens focuses,
  • My meter works,
  • My color development technique was within tolerance and
  • My color inversion s/w did what I wanted it to do.

So you see what one-shot meant to me with all of these variables in question.

Perhaps a future article will have more photographs and fewer links?

 

Share this post:

Find more similar content on 35mmc

Use the tags below to search for more posts on related topics:

Contribute to 35mmc for an ad-free experience.

There are two ways to contribute to 35mmc and experience it without the adverts:

Paid Subscription – £2.99 per month and you’ll never see an advert again! (Free 3-day trial).

Subscribe here.

Content contributor – become a part of the world’s biggest film and alternative photography community blog. All our Contributors have an ad-free experience for life.

Sign up here.

About The Author

By Gary Smith
Gary has been shooting photographs for 50+ years using a variety of film and digital cameras. For a time, he was employed in the software industry as an interface designer. He has once again been shooting film on a variety of cameras he was never able to own 50 years ago and has begun developing and scanning both black and white and color films during the past 14 months. He lives in the state of Oregon in the Pacific Northwest area of the USA.
View Profile

Comments

Jeffery Luhn on Validation – A One-shot Story

Comment posted: 02/03/2025

Gary,
It seems as though all the hoops you had to jump through gave you a good result! I'm sorry to hear your lens issue was a disaster, but you conquered it. I do not have the cojones to try a repair on a lens like that.

I've been a Nikon devote' for my entire photo life. I feel it's a very good brand because there are so many F mount lenses that work well on my film Nikons as well as my digital Nikons. I also have an adaptor that allows me to use old Nikon lenses on a Sony A6000 crop sensor digital camera. I'll probably never be able to justify buying a Leica 35mm, so the 'blue collar' Nikons are good enough for me. Tests I've run with my Leica friends confirm that prime Nikon and good quality prime Canon lenses for film don't fall far behind Leica. I'll probably never be able to justify buying a Leica 35mm, so the 'blue collar' Nikons are good enough for me. There is, of course, the undeniable pride of owning Leica or Contax, but that's grist for another time.

I recommend that you get a few manual prime Nikkor lenses because they are inexpensive and super sharp. Make sure they are AI vintage or newer so they link to your camera meter. The AI means the lens has a little flange on it to couple with Nikon internal meters. Nikon added that feature in 1977, so most vintage lenses being sold today have that feature. Here's a link from Nikon with photos.
https://www.nikonimgsupport.com/na/NSG_article?articleNo=000048608&configured=1&lang=en_SG
Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Gary Smith replied:

Comment posted: 02/03/2025

Thanks Jeffery! I recently purchased a Nikkor 35/2 for the FE as well as a Nikkor 150/5.6 for the Toyo 45A 4 x 5 camera. You might want to take a look at Richard Haw's Nikon maintenance site mentioned above. It was the only reason that I was able to fix that e-series lens.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Jeffery Luhn on Validation – A One-shot Story

Comment posted: 02/03/2025

Gary,
It seems as though all the hoops you had to jump through gave you a good result! I'm sorry to hear your lens issue was a disaster, but you conquered it. I do not have the cojones to try a repair on a lens like that.

I've been a Nikon devote' for my entire photo life. I feel it's a very good brand because there are so many F mount lenses that work well on my film Nikons as well as my digital Nikons. I also have an adaptor that allows me to use old Nikon lenses on a Sony A6000 crop sensor digital camera. I'll probably never be able to justify buying a Leica 35mm, so the 'blue collar' Nikons are good enough for me. Tests I've run with my Leica friends confirm that prime Nikon and good quality prime Canon lenses for film don't fall far behind Leica. I'll probably never be able to justify buying a Leica 35mm, so the 'blue collar' Nikons are good enough for me. There is, of course, the undeniable pride of owning Leica or Contax, but that's grist for another time.

I recommend that you get a few manual prime Nikkor lenses because they are inexpensive and super sharp. Make sure they are AI vintage or newer so they link to your camera meter. The AI means the lens has a little flange on it to couple with Nikon internal meters. Nikon added that feature in 1977, so most vintage lenses being sold today have that feature. Here's a link from Nikon with photos.
https://www.nikonimgsupport.com/na/NSG_article?articleNo=000048608&configured=1&lang=en_SG
Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RichardH on Validation – A One-shot Story

Comment posted: 02/03/2025

Gary: Congratulations! Lens repair is not for the timid. C41 film developing, too! I admire your technical skill.
Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Gary Smith replied:

Comment posted: 02/03/2025

It turned out that it wasn't a big deal (but I suppose it could have been). The C41 development is a work in progress. I have 2 additional rolls currently loaded in two different cameras. I'll be curious to see how they turn out. It amuses me that I can go out with a digital camera a knock off three dozen shots easily whereas with film, it takes more time.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Jukka Reimola on Validation – A One-shot Story

Comment posted: 03/03/2025

Well done, Gary! I guess, if you've fixed watches, the lens operation must've been a piece of cake. I wear a Seiko Automatic with a display back and wouldn't tamper with the intricate clockwork at any cost.
Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Gary Smith replied:

Comment posted: 03/03/2025

Hi Jukka, The bit that I did turned out to be really easy once I had the detailed disassembly/assembly instructions from Richard's web site. If you own old Nikons it would be worth your time to visit that site. Here is another informative web page that shows you a LOT of details on mechanical watches: https://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch/

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Alexander Seidler on Validation – A One-shot Story

Comment posted: 03/03/2025

Congratulations
Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *